Kya munkeer e hadees pagal ho chukke hai ?
Pagle yeh bol rahe hai ki ISA (as) ki bhi hadeese laake do kyun ki humne hadeeso ko manne ke liye Qur'an ki yeh ayat di jisme likha hai ki "Rasool bejha jo humko kitab aur hikmat ki taleem deta hai" (Qur'an 2:151) To iss ayat se Muhammad ﷺ ki Hadeeso ko manna Saabit hota hain.
Dusari ayat hai jisme ISA (as) ki hadeeso ko manna bhi saabit hota hain wo ayat yeh hai "Aur wohi ( Allah ) uss ko ( yani essa ibn-e-maryam ko ) kitab o hikmat aur toraat o injeel ki taleem dey ga" .
(Qur'an 3:48)
To yeh ayat deke kehte hai ki humko ISA (as) ki bhi hadeese do kyun ki Hikmat ki Taleem ISA (as) to denge kaha hain fir Isa (as) ki taleem (hadeese)
Ab kya kahu inki akal par hans hi sakta hu inko lagta hain ki inhone bahut badi daleel dedi ab to jeet gaye khushi mana rahe hai inko bhi pata hai humare pass ISA (as) ki hadeese hai hi nahi to hum denge kaise inko .
Lekeen ek baat sayad inlogo ne note nahi ki wo yeh ki issi ayat mai kitaab ka bhi kaha gaya hai ji haan kitaab Torah aur injeel ka to hum bhi demand karte hai inse ki aap bhi humko kitaab (Torah aur injeel) do jo ISA (as) par nazeel hue hain .
Qur'an ko hi injeel aur Torah na keh dena kyun ki Qur'an to Muhammad ﷺ par nazeel hue hai yeh Qur'an hai Torah nahi jo musa (as) par Nazeel hue, Yeh injeel bhi nahi jo iSa (as) par nazeel hue, Yeh to Qur'an hai jo Muhammad ﷺ par Nazeel hue .
Humko to wo Torah dedo jo Musa (as) par Nazeel hue
Humko to wo injeel dedo jo iSa (as) par Nazeel hue
Fir hum vichar karege Musa (as) aur iSa (as) ki hadeese dene ka .
Kya inko pata nahi ki Torah aur injeel ki hifazat ki zimedaari Allah ney nahi li thi isliye naa Aaj humare pass Musa (as) ki Torah hai naa Humare pass isa (as) ki injeel hai Naa hi unki hadeese hain .
 ki Hadees kaha hai){kind=link}